How To Choose The Best Bait For Mouse Traps? 🧀🧀

So, you have already moved on to a humane way to get rid of mice and got a no-kill mousetrap. Well done! That is the first step you must take to make sure you’re house is rodent-free. But you will also need bait to lure the mice into the trap. In this article, we are going to take a more in-depth look into the best bait for mouse traps.

Mice are smart creatures that can turn your home into their playground if you don’t take immediate action. They multiply very quickly, and on average, a female mouse has 30 to 35 babies per year. So, if you see a mouse running away, there’s a 100% chance that their number will increase soon. Unless, of course, you will do everything to stop that.

Mouse with cheese illustration by Cassie Shawver
Credit @madampuddleduck

Now, there are many ways to prevent mice from getting into your home. One of them is filling every hole or crack so that the little creatures can’t get inside. Remember that a mouse can squeeze through a 0.7-inch hole! And if you live in an old house, there will be a lot of work patching all these cracks. But if mice are already in your home, the only way to deal with them is by using a mousetrap. By knowing the tips and tricks on how to outsmart these creatures, you will be able to deal with mice in no time.

First of all, you need to identify the areas in your home where you noticed their activity. Mice love hidden areas like behind cabinets or the stove and will walk along the perimeter of walls where they can easily navigate using their whiskers. Also, they have excellent vision and hearing with a high sense of smell and touch. In other words, you are dealing with a smart creature, so you need to use the most advanced techniques. To catch mice that are already in your home, you will need an effective mousetrap and the best bait for it.

How to choose the best bait for mouse traps?

Even if you own the most high-tech mousetrap on the market, it will be worthless without a proper mouse bait. Since mice have a superior smell, it is clear that the best bait for mouse traps is one with a strong odor. So, there is no need to buy specialized food – you can use products that you already have in your home. Let’s take a look at what the best foods for mouse trap baits are.

6 Best Bait for Mouse Traps

Now that you have an effective mousetrap and know mice’s behavior, you should take a look at the best mouse trap baits that will help you to catch them. Most of these bait options are items that you can find in your home kitchen, making them easily accessible.

1. Peanut or Hazelnut Butter

Peanut butter mouse trap bait
Peanut butter is one of the cheapest mouse trap bait options

Forget the idea that cheese is the best bait for mouse traps. Although cheese does have a strong smell, peanut butter has a more significant impact. Naturally, mice love nuts and seeds, so there is no better bait than peanut butter. You will only need a drop the size of a pea to lure the mice into the trap.

🛒 Buy 16 oz Creamy Peanut Butter for $11.70

Since you are using a non-lethal mousetrap, make sure you place a few tiny drops of peanut butter near the holes. Then, add some bait further so that the mouse can’t reach it. A mouse will lick the food close to the holes and will then want to eat the rest of it by getting inside the trap.

2. Cheese

Cheese is the best mouse bait in terms of aroma. Mice can smell it from a distance, and it is also one of their delicacies. Make sure you use a hard cheese.

3. Protein (Sausage bits or Bacon)

Best bait for mouse traps bacon bits
Bacon bits are another great mouse trap bait option

Mice love protein foods, whether they are cooked or raw, and it gets the job done. Again, put some of the bait near the holes of the mousetrap and some further from them. Place the trap in the area where you find mice droppings, and you will be surprised how much you will catch them.

🛒 Buy McCormick Culinary Bacon Bits from Amazon

4. Sweet Foods

Just like humans, mice also have a sweet tooth. They love sweet foods, and it is another option for the best bait for mouse traps. You can use dark chocolate or even a gummy bear!

5. Yarn, Dental Floss, and Cotton Balls

These are a different kind of baits because they provide the most necessary material that mice look for when they build their nests during the winter. When the temperature drops below zero, mice seek shelter indoors, so these baits are another way to lure them into the trap.

6. Cat or Dog Food

Dog food as mouse trap bait
Dog food is another option for mouse trap bait

Pet owners have learned the importance of putting pet food in safe places because mice can even eat through plastic bags! Dry dog food is a delicacy for mice. So, you can test it yourself and place a dog or cat food into the mousetrap.

🛒 Buy small amount of dog food from Amazon

How to Properly Bait The Mousetrap?

Even if you’re using the best bait for mouse traps, you must take certain precautions to ensure that it does not diminish your chances of success.

1. Wear Gloves

Always wear gloves when you are baiting the mousetrap or releasing the caught mice free. It is crucial because the gloves prevent you from leaving your scent in the trap. Mice have a strong smell and can easily detect your presence, which will deter them from going for the bait.

You also need to wear gloves when releasing the mice free because they may be sick. Since you are using a reusable non-lethal mousetrap, you can wash it with warm water and soap and use it as many times as you need.

2. Take Immediate Action As Soon As You Notice Mice in Your Home

To increase the chances of catching mice – place mousetraps as soon as you notice their presence. Inspect the areas that they visit the most and place mousetraps with the best bait. For maximum effect, use at least two or three traps and strategically place around your home.

You are more likely to catch most of them on the first day than the following days.

3. Don’t Expect Quick Results

As soon as you get a new mousetrap, you might think that you will get instant results. Unfortunately, to lure the mice into the trap, you will need to place it in their beloved areas. You may get lucky and spot these areas right away. But more realistically, you will need to test different mouse trap baits and places until you achieve the results.

4. Use Small Amount of Best Bait For Mouse Traps

Using too much bait is not the right way of doing it. If you place too much of it near the holes, the mice will lick it off without getting into the trap. By feeding them with too much bait, you will grow their colony.

5. Use Enough Mouse Traps

Non-lethal mouse trap
Invest in a non-lethal reusable mousetrap

To achieve the best results, use at least two mouse traps. If you live in a bigger house, you can even get three or four. Since you are using a multi-catch non-lethal mousetrap, there is no need to buy a lot of them because one such trap can catch up to 5 mice at a time. Make sure you check the live catch traps regularly (every two to three hours) because the mice can die from stress.

🛒 Buy This Mouse Trap for $12.99 from Amazon

6. Keep Changing the Bait

When you find the best bait for mouse traps, don’t forget to change it from time to time. Always use only fresh food – otherwise, it will rot and turn into a mice repellent.

What to Do if Your Mouse Bait Is Ineffective?

If a specific mousetrap bait doesn’t work the way you expected, here are the things you should do:

  • Try other types of mousetrap bait and see which one is more efficient.
  • If you are using a lethal trap, consider getting a non-lethal mousetrap. It is much more efficient because it allows you to catch multiple mice at a time.
  • A spring-loaded mousetrap also might not catch small mice. Yet another reason to move on to a humane mousetrap.
  • Change the location of the trap. Inspect the areas that the mice visit most and place the mousetrap there.

Other Things to Consider

Start by limiting the location of the trap to a single area. Then, show your family members the places where you put the mousetraps. Many people are scared of live mice, so they must be aware that you are using a live-catch trap.

To find the areas that mice visit the most, look for their small black droppings – these are the first signs of their presence. Place the traps where you discover their activity.

Keep in mind that mice build their nests in safe places where there is heat, mainly behind appliances such as refrigerators, water heaters, and ovens. So, inspect these areas thoroughly, and make sure you fix every hole or crack if there’s any.

Finally, keep using the mouse trap until you no longer catch any mice. Check the traps regularly (from three to four times a day), and change the bait to keep it fresh. You can never be sure whether you have caught them all. So, keep the traps for some time, even if you think that the mice are gone.

Final Thoughts

Finding the best bait for mouse traps is not so difficult. Although the wide variety of bait options and the ingenuity of mice may complicate your task, sooner or later, you will get rid of them. Follow the tips above, and make sure you fix all holes and cracks inside your home.